Senior Lecturer in Latin American History
Department of History
University of Liverpool
(Liverpool, UK)
Andrew Redden currently works as a senior lecturer in Latin American history at the University of Liverpool, England. His first book, Diabolism in Colonial Peru, 1560-1750 (Routledge, Taylor & Francis, 2008), came out of his PhD investigation into the interaction between demons and the population of colonial Peru. It centered on the diverse ways in which the perceived presence of demons was experienced and utilized by members of the various cultures that coexisted and intermingled in the viceroyalty. This led to a wider project researching the presence of angels and demons in the early modern Hispanic world, with a particular focus on the viceroyalties of New Spain (modern Mexico), Peru (including modern Bolivia and Chile), and New Granada (modern Colombia and Venezuela), but also including Spain and southern Italy. Based on archival materials, theological treatises, and religious art, this research assessed the various ways in which these spiritual beings affected human lives. He published a co-edited anthology of essays together with Fernando Cervantes in 2013: Angels, Demons, and the New World (Cambridge UP, 2013).
Andrew's work on angels and demons also fed into a wider interest in missions and missionary methodology. This work has resulted in a number of publications, including an open-access, bilingual, critical edition of Antonio de la Calancha's 1638 account of the martyrdom of the Augustinian friar Diego Ortiz, in Vilcabamba, Peru (1571): The Collapse of Time: The Martyrdom of Diego Ortiz (1571) by Antonio de la Calancha [1638] (DeGruyter Open Poland, 2016). He has also worked on slavery and African witchcraft in colonial New Granada, and conscience on early modern Hispanic frontiers. These studies incorporate a much broader interest in global missions and, more generally, the transmission of religious ideas and practice in the early modern period throughout the Hispanic world, as well as the conflicts and sometimes surprising accommodations that resulted.
In 2013, a chance encounter with the founder of Music for Hope at an activist event in Manchester gave Andrew's research a new direction. He was inspired by the project which taught music to young people and children in El Salvador as part of a community-based cultural counter-violence strategy. He volunteered and visited the teachers and participants in El Salvador that year. Since then, he has continued working with the organization, visiting as and when he can, and helped in its conversion from an NGO to a registered charity in 2016. He is now a trustee of the charity and is currently working on a documentary history of the project, looking to understand how it has developed and what impact it has had and continues to have on the lives of the participants. As part of that work, he has filmed short documentaries and facilitated storytelling and song-writing workshops with the young participants, returning subsequently to record and produce the songs that were written in an album: Historias cantadas siempre vivirán (Stories that are Sung, Live Forever). This work has entered a new phase with the teachers and young musicians drawing from and conserving their cultural and historical heritage as they continue to write and record new songs.
Conference Presentation—Seeing Idolatry: Devotion, Divergence, and Dogma in the Latin American Colonial and Postcolonial Experience
In October 2019, a Pan-Amazonian synod was held in Rome, and the ceremony of dedication to St. Francis took place in the Vatican gardens. With Pope Francis and cardinals present and seated, delegates (who included a Franciscan friar) sang and danced around a circular cloth embroidered with images representative of the Amazon and spread out on the ground. On top of the cloth were placed various objects and--considered most controversial--a carving of naked male with an erect phallus and two carved wooden figurines of a pregnant, naked, earth-mother that a delegate referred to as "Nuestra Señora de la Amazonia" (Our Lady of the Amazon) but to whom Pope Francis and Vatican representatives later referred to as "Pachamama." After dancing, the delegates bowed down before the objects. The "Pachamamas" were ceremonially processed into St. Peter’s Basilica, then installed in a side altar of the Basilica of Santa Maria in Traspontina, and all of these ceremonies (the dedication and installation) were filmed and distributed on the internet. After watching these ceremonies, two Austrian Catholics flew to Rome, removed the statues from the Basilica and threw them into the Tiber River. The polemic that both the ceremony and subsequent act of iconoclasm generated was vitriolic. The bishop emeritus of Marajó, José Luis Azcona Hermoso, for example, condemned the association of "Pachamama" with the Virgin Mary as "a lie" and "scandalous demonic sacrilege," and Bishop Athanasius Schneider of Astana, Kazakhstan, hailed the Austrian iconoclasts as "new Maccabees" and the Pachamama statues as "the new Golden Calf." Pope Francis, meanwhile, apologized for any offense caused by the Austrian men’s actions.
The association of the Virgin Mary with Pachamama is not new, however, nor are the discourses that extol the virtues of syncretic practices leading indigenous Americans towards salvation, or which condemn them as diabolical usurpations of the truth causing the damnation of all those who practice them. During the colonial period (16th-18th centuries), rites considered harmless or even beneficial cultural practices by some clergy were condemned by others as sinister, demonic idolatry. At the same time, the very process of evangelization gave rise to new meanings, concepts, and even entities. Devotions to Mary were no exception. This paper will consider aspects of these colonial devotions and the challenges they posed before returning to the polemic of the Pan-Amazonian Synod which will be reconsidered in the light of this analysis, raising questions about the discourse of idolatry and the implications of dogmatic claims of universal truth linked to very specific understandings of doctrine.